Phil Mullins
mullins@missouriwestern.edu
“Scientific Outlook: Its Sickness and Cure” (hereafter SOISC), was published in the March 18, 1957 issue of Science (v. 125, no. 3246, 480-484). This essay is an extraordinarily compressed discussion—so much so that it is difficult to follow the argument and see how the components here fit together. There are nine brief sections in approximately 5500 words; no section is longer than a few paragraphs and one important one is a single paragraph.
Polanyi was invited to give a paper in a symposium on “‘fundamental units and concepts of science'” (see the note at the bottom of 480) at a late December 1956 New York meeting of the American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS).1 Immediately after this meeting, he was apparently invited by Science to write a brief response to the equally brief written comments of three of the symposium’s presenters, Robert MacLeod2 (a psychologist), R. W. Gerard3 (a neurologist and neurophysiologist), and Jerrold Zacharias4 (a physicist). These three scientists’ abbreviated essays and Polanyi’s very compacted response (i.e., SOISC) were published as a set of short articles in early 1957 in two successive issues of Science.
Polanyi was in late 1956 and early 1957, as the Polanyi biographers Scott and Moleski suggest (2005, 230), in the final stage of putting together Personal Knowledge, the richest to date articulation of his ideas, which was not actually published until June 20, 1958.5 What Polanyi attempts in this very concise Science essay is to criticize but also to transform and enlarge some ideas sketched in the brief written comments of each of the three AAAS symposium participants. The broader argument in the forthcoming Personal Knowledge seems to lie in the near background of SOISC. That is, Polanyi very parsimoniously outlines his critical case against much in the mainstream account of science and society as well as his alternative constructive (i.e., post-critical) epistemological case for personal knowledge. But in SOISC, Polanyi clearly is also digging deeply into the brief written essays of MacLeod, Gerhard, and Zaccharias. And especially important in SOISC (and in other writing published in the eight months prior to this Science article) is the very direct statement of Polanyi’s socio-political philosophical convictions. These convictions are an integral component of his post-critical account and they also, of course, appear in Personal Knowledge (especially in Chapter 7, “Conviviality”). The articulation of these socio-political convictions in SOISC (and in several other essays from this period) reflects Polanyi’s deep involvement in programs of the Congress for Cultural Freedom and his analysis of contemporary Cold War global politics and particularly his response to events surrounding the 1956 Hungarian Revolution. 6
Polanyi was the last of four presenters in the AAAS symposium (and was invited as a special guest) and he very likely gave a talk primarily outlining his own ideas (drawing from his forthcoming Personal Knowledge) rather than focusing on ideas of MacLeod, Gerhard, and Zaccharias who had presented on the previous day and were critiqued by speakers other than Polanyi after they spoke. In the Michael Polanyi Papers (MPP), there is an archival typescript (21 pages) that has a title almost identical to SOISC, “The Scientific Outlook: Its Sickness and Cure” (Box 33, Folder 11, 0477-0497, MPP), and this document has some puzzling features. At the top of the first page of this document (Box 33, Folder 11, 0477, MPP) is handwritten “published 1957” but also typed just below is “Austin, 30 Nov. 1958” (Box 33, Folder 11, 0477, MPP). Immediately preceding this archival text in the MPP (in the numbered digital version of Folder 11) there is what appears to be another copy of the document but with the title “The Outlook of Science: Its Sickness and Cure” (Box 33, Folder 11, 0456-0476, MPP). This document’s title, its designation of authorship (i.e., “by Michael Polanyi”) and a note (“Austin, 30 Nov. 1958”) at the top of the first page are all handwritten. “The Scientific Outlook: Its Sickness and Cure” is a retyped (with some typographical corrections and revisions) and retitled version of “The Outlook of Science: Its Sickness and Cure.”
Neither of these two archival documents makes any references to MacLeod, Gerhard or Zacharias. However, these documents do discuss basic ideas underlying the project of writing Personal Knowledge.7 And they comment on the subtitle of Personal Knowledge, “Towards a Post-Critical Philosophy.” Polanyi suggested that the era of modern critical thought was coming to an end and that he anticipated the coming of a new era in thought which will transform contemporary understandings of science and society (see Box 33, Folder 11, 0486-0487, MPP). Apparently, “The Scientific Outlook: Its Sickness and Cure” (Box 33, Folder 11, 0477-0497, MPP) and “The Outlook of Science: Its Sickness and Cure” (Box 33, Folder 11, 0456-0476, MPP) are texts for a lecture that Polanyi delivered in Austin, Texas on November 30, 1958 when he was visiting William H. Poteat who was teaching at the Episcopal Seminary; Scott and Moleski, (2005, 235) tell a charming story about this Polanyi visit.8
Nevertheless, although it is not identified as such, it seems likely that this 1958 Austin lecture is a somewhat redacted version of what Polanyi delivered on December 28, 1956 at the AAAS symposium. Some of the very abbreviated and confusing discussions in sections of SOISC seem to be very condensed statements about topics discussed in this Austin lecture. Interestingly, a few of the sentences Polanyi included in SOISC were clearly intended to be clever and humorous. Most notable is Polanyi’s sharp criticism of functionalist anthropology: he argued that focusing exclusively on how practices contribute to social stability produces an anthropological account that fails to make important distinctions. He wittily summarized his criticism in SOISC in this way: “Pickpockets and prophets, Hitler and Gandhi, Jesus of Nazareth and Judas Iskariot are all classed together as deviants” (482). This colorful line also appears in the archival text that was a 1958 lecture in Austin (p. 21 [Box 33, Folder 11, 0497, MPP]). It seems likely that Polanyi mined his original AAAS symposium address presented as the final panelist on December 28, 1956 in order to produce some of SOISC and then later recycled (with some redactions) his original AAAS address to produce his Austin lecture on November 30, 1958. Polanyi often used earlier written material to generate later texts.
Thanks go to Dr. John Polanyi, literary executor for Michael Polanyi, for giving permission to the Polanyi Society to post this essay for non-commercial use by students and scholars.
Works Cited
Coleman, Peter. 2006. “A Note on Michael Polanyi and the Congress for Cultural Freedom,” Polanyiana 2006 1/2 (15): 56-64.
Gelwick, Richard L. 1963. Collected Articles and Papers of Michael Polanyi. Berkeley, CA: Pacific School of Religion. This copyrighted microfilm collection compiled by Richard L. Gelwick (Microfilm 4008 in the Graduate Theological Union Library, Berkeley, CA) was digitized in 2014 by Phil Mullins and made available on the Polanyi Society web site at https://www.polanyisociety.org/Glwk-micro/Gelwick-microfilm.htm.
_____. 1968. “A Bibliography of Michael Polanyi’s Social and Philosophical Writings. In Intellect and Hope, Essays in the Thought of Michael Polanyi. Durham. William H Poteat, and Thomas A. Langford (eds.). Durham, N.C.: Duke University Press: 432-446.
Gerard, R. W. 1957, March 8. “Units and Concepts of Biology,” Science, v. 125 no. 3245: 429-433.
MacLeod, Robert.1957, March 15. “Teleology and Theory of Human Behavior,” Science, v. 125 no. 3246: 477-480.
Mullins, Phil. 2023. Review of Campaigning Culture and the Global Cold War: The Journals of the Congress for Freedom
by Giles Scott-Smith and Charlotte Lerg (eds.). Tradition and Discovery 49(1): 46-48.
Polanyi, Michael. 1956, June. “The Magic of Marxism.” The Bulletin of Atomic Scientists, v. 12: 211-214, 232.
_____. 1956, November. “The Magic of Marxism.” Science and Freedom, Bulletin of the Committee on Science and Freedom (special supplement): 6-19.
_____. 1956, November. “The Next Stage of History, An Appeal for Intellectual Co-Operation.” Science and Freedom, Bulletin of the Committee on Science and Freedom (special supplement): 21-24.
_____. 1956, December. “The Magic of Marxism.” Encounter, v.7: 5-17 [includes “Author’s Preface,” 5-6].
_____. 1957, March 15.” Scientific Outlook: Its Sickness and Cure.” Science, v. 125, no. 3246: 480-484.
_____. 1958 “The Outlook of Science: Its Sickness and Cure.” Box 33, Folder 11, 0456-0476. Michael Polanyi Papers. Hanna Holborn Gray Special Collections Research Center, University of Chicago Library.
_____.1958. Personal Knowledge: Towards a Post-Critical Philosophy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press/London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, Ltd.(1964 Harper Torchbook Edition cited here).
_____. 1958 “The Scientific Outlook: Its Sickness and Cure.” Box 33, Folder 11, 0477-0497. Michael Polanyi Papers. Hanna Holborn Gray Special Collections Research Center, University of Chicago Library.
Poteat, William H and Thomas A. Langford (eds.). 1968. Intellect and Hope, Essays in the Thought of Michael Polanyi. Durham, N.C.: Duke University Press.
Prust, Richard Charles. 1970. The Knowledge and Reality of God: The Theological Implications of Michael Polanyi’s Epistemology and Ontology. Ph.D. Dissertation, Duke University.
Scott, William Taussig and Martin X. Moleski, S.J. 2005. Michael Polanyi, Scientist and Philosopher. Oxford University Press.
Taylor, Raymond L. 1957, February 15. “New York Meeting in Retrospect.” Science, v. 125, no. 3242: 285-291.
Zacharias, Jerrold. 1957, March 8. “Structure of Physical Science,” Science, v. 125 no. 3245: 427-428.
End Notes
1 See Raymond Taylor’s 15 February 1957 report on the session in “New York Meeting in Retrospect” in Science (vol. 125, no. 3242: 288, online at https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.125.3242.285). See the discussion below for references to archival Polanyi material that very likely is what Polanyi actually presented in this New York meeting on December 28, 1956.
2 “Teleology and Theory of Human Behavior,” Science, 15 March 1957, vol. 125 no. 3246: 477-480, online at https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.125.3246.477.
3 “Units and Concepts of Biology,” Science, 8 March 1957, vol. 125 no. 3245: 429-433, online at https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.125.3245.429. Polanyi likely knew at least some things about Gerard’s views before the late 1956 AAAS meeting after which Gerard produced the short 1957 Science essay that Polanyi sharply criticized.
Gerhard was a participant in the 1951 Hixon Symposium which Polanyi was interested in. See Personal Knowledge, 340, footnote 2.
4 “Structure of Physical Science,” Science, 18 March 1957, vol. 125 no. 3245: 427-428, online at https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.125.3245.427.
5 Scott and Moleski (2005, 230) provide this publication date. The pagination in the 1964 Harper Torchbook Edition of Personal Knowledge is cited hereafter.
6 Social-political and epistemological themes are woven seamlessly together in Personal Knowledge, along with certain evolutionary and cosmological themes and certain elements of Lebensphilosphie. This complexity unfolds as each of the four divisions of Polanyi’s magnum opus supplements its predecessor. However, Personal Knowledge is a 405-page discussion and not a 4.5-page response, as is SOISC, to three articulate scientists who provided only brief comments. For brief discussions of Polanyi’s involvement in the Congress for Cultural Freedom see Peter Coleman, 2006 and Mullins, 2022. Polanyi focused on the role of moral passions in shaping modern culture. In the ten months prior to publication of SOISC, Polanyi’s publications treating moral passions and Marxism, global politics, and the 1956 Hungarian Revolution are akin to ideas very briefly noted in SOISC. See particularly Polanyi’s three versions of “The Magic of Marxism” (and supplemental material) published just prior to SOISC (see all 1956 Polanyi references) as well as the section titled “The Magic of Marxism” in Personal Knowledge (227-233).
7 At the end of “The Scientific Outlook: Its Sickness and Cure,” Polanyi concludes that there is an “overwhelming ubiquitous compulsion” operating in the “minds of contemporary scientists” but “no minor revision of our present conception of science is likely to meet the situation and repair the damage.” Polanyi affirms that “the deepest obstacle to regeneration lies in the fact that the acknowledgement of comprehensive entities of which we cannot specify the particulars is repugnant to the principles of critical reason. This acknowledgement cannot be restored without radically restricting our critical faculties in the interest of the truth. This will be very difficult.” (p.21 [Box 33, Folder 11, 0497, MPP]).
8 Richard Charles Prust, one of Poteat’s later Duke graduate students, discusses Polanyi’s ideas about the post-critical era and quotes from “The Outlook of Science: Its Sickness and Cure” in his 1970 dissertation (“The Knowledge and Reality of God: The Theological Implications of Michael Polanyi’s Epistemology and Ontology,” Duke University, 1970. pp.5-6) supervised by Poteat. Polanyi possibly gave Poteat a copy of this draft of his Austin lecture and Poteat may later have provided Prust a copy of the text several years before the MPP was assembled after Polanyi’s 1976 death. There is a copy of “The Outlook of Science: Its Sickness and Cure” in the Gelwick microfilm collection of Polanyi materials (as well as a copy of SOISC) and Prust may have acquired a copy from this microfilm since the Gelwick microfilm collection was available (copyright 1963) when Prust was working on his dissertation. In 1968, Intellect and Hope: Essays in the Thought of Michael Polanyi, which was edited by Thomas A. Langford and William H. Poteat, was published. This festschrift included Richard Gelwick’s updated version of the Polanyi bibliography provided in the Gelwick microfilm collection (Langford and Poteat, 1968, 432-446). This updated bibliography includes a 1958 entry for “The Outlook of Science: Its Sickness and Cure” which is identified as the typescript of a November 1958 lecture given by Polanyi in Austin, Texas (440).